Leasing means lower monthly payments. Buying means you own something at the end. But which actually costs less over time? Here's how to think through this common car dilemma.
How Leasing Works
When you lease, you're essentially renting the car for a set period (usually 2-3 years). You pay for the vehicle's depreciation during that time, plus interest and fees—not the full purchase price.
- Monthly payment: Based on depreciation + money factor (interest)
- At lease end: Return the car or buy it at residual value
- Mileage limit: Usually 10,000-15,000 miles/year
- Wear & tear: Charged for excessive damage
How Buying Works
When you buy (finance), you're paying for the entire vehicle over time. Once the loan is paid off, you own it outright and can keep driving payment-free.
- Monthly payment: Based on full price minus down payment
- At loan end: You own the car, no more payments
- No mileage limit: Drive as much as you want
- Sell anytime: It's your asset
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Leasing | Buying |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | Lower | Higher |
| Down payment | Often $0 | Usually 10-20% |
| Ownership at end | None | Full ownership |
| Long-term cost | Higher (perpetual payments) | Lower (payment-free years) |
| Mileage limits | 10-15K/year (fees if over) | Unlimited |
| Customization | Not allowed | Do what you want |
| Maintenance | Usually under warranty | Your responsibility |
| Latest features | New car every 2-3 years | Keep same car longer |
| Credit requirements | Usually need 700+ | More flexible |
The Math: 6-Year Comparison
Let's compare leasing vs. buying a $40,000 car over 6 years:
📋 Leasing (2 × 3-year leases)
- Monthly payment: $450 × 72 months
- Total paid: $32,400
- What you own: Nothing
🔑 Buying (5-year loan, keep 6 years)
- Monthly payment: $750 × 60 months = $45,000
- Year 6: $0 payments
- Car value at year 6: ~$14,000
- Net cost: $31,000
In this example, buying costs less overall and you still have a car worth $14,000. But leasing had lower monthly payments during those years.
💡 The Key Insight
Leasing is cheaper month-to-month but more expensive over time. Buying costs more upfront but leads to payment-free years once the loan ends.
When Leasing Makes Sense
✅ Lease if you...
Want a new car every 2-3 years • Drive under 12,000 miles/year • Value low monthly payments • Want to always be under warranty • Can write off lease payments for business • Don't want to deal with selling/trading
Good Lease Candidates
- Business owners: Lease payments may be tax-deductible
- Low-mileage drivers: Work from home, urban living
- Tech enthusiasts: Want latest safety/infotainment features
- Luxury shoppers: Lease a BMW for price of buying a Honda
When Buying Makes Sense
✅ Buy if you...
Drive more than 12,000 miles/year • Plan to keep the car 5+ years • Want to own an asset • Like to customize your vehicle • Have kids/pets (wear & tear) • Want no payment eventually
Good Buy Candidates
- Long commuters: High mileage = lease penalties
- Long-term thinkers: Keep car 8-10 years, save thousands
- Families: Stains and scratches happen
- Budget maximizers: Payment-free years are powerful
Watch Out For These Lease Traps
⚠️ Hidden Lease Costs
- Mileage overage: $0.15-0.30 per mile over limit (5,000 extra miles = $750-$1,500)
- Wear & tear fees: Dings, stains, tire wear can cost hundreds
- Disposition fee: $300-500 charged when you return the car
- Early termination: Breaking a lease early is very expensive
- GAP insurance: Usually required (sometimes included)
Lease Negotiation Tips
If you decide to lease, negotiate these factors:
- Capitalized cost (cap cost): The "price" of the car—negotiate just like buying
- Money factor: The interest rate—multiply by 2,400 to get APR equivalent
- Residual value: Higher is better (means less depreciation to pay)
- Mileage allowance: Get more upfront—cheaper than overage fees
- Fees: Ask to waive acquisition and disposition fees
Quick Decision Framework
🎯 The Bottom Line
- Best financial outcome: Buy a 2-3 year old car, keep 8+ years
- If you must have new: Buy and keep 6+ years
- If monthly payment is priority: Lease, but know you're paying more long-term
- High mileage driver: Buy (always)
- Business use: Lease may offer tax advantages—consult accountant
A Third Option: Lease Buyout
Some people lease, then buy the car at lease-end for the residual value. This can work if:
- The car is worth more than the residual (you got a deal)
- You've taken great care of it
- You want to keep driving it payment-free
Check the buyout price before your lease ends—sometimes it's a smart move.
🚗 Calculate Your Car Payment
Whether you lease or buy, see what fits your budget.
Open Auto Loan Calculator